New York Law Watch
Week ending June 6, 2026
4 decision records: 4 meet the substance floor.
Decision dates in this week are June 4, 2026, from 1 court.
By court
Appellate Term, Second Department
- Water’s Edge 32 Limited Partnership v Bailey2026 NY Slip Op 51292[U]
The Appellate Term affirmed the lower court’s judgment awarding possession to the landlord because the tenant breached the lease by repeatedly refusing access for necessary repairs. The court held that the tenant’s failure to seek leave for discovery prior to trial precluded her from presenting security camera footage.
- Sialiano v Costco Wholesale2026 NY Slip Op 51291[U]
The judgment dismissing the small claims action was affirmed because the plaintiff failed to meet the burden of proving the amount of damages. The plaintiff did not provide expert testimony or two itemized repair estimates for the unrepaired vehicle damage.
- People v Bruner2026 NY Slip Op 51290[U]
The court reversed the convictions and dismissed the simplified traffic informations because the People failed to serve the requested supporting depositions. The defendant’s motion to dismiss was deemed timely because it was made before the commencement of the trial, as no arraignment had occurred.
- Hernandez v Lakeview Arms Apts.2026 NY Slip Op 51289[U]
The Appellate Term affirmed the dismissal of the small claims action, finding that substantial justice was done because the tenant admitted to causing damage beyond ordinary wear and tear. The court held that the property manager’s credible testimony regarding repair costs was sufficient to justify retaining the security deposit, even without itemized bills, given the small amount involved.
Published June 6, 2026. Updated November 14, 2026.